Skip to main content
Marhardt Consulting
Back to The Journey

The Small Business Website Playbook · Part 8 of 11

Questions to Ask a Marketing Agency Before You Sign a Retainer

By
Questions to Ask a Marketing Agency Before You Sign a Retainer

The proposal looks professional. It has a monthly number at the bottom, a twelve month term, and a page of services you half understand. The salesperson is pleasant and wants an answer by Friday. What you do not have is any way to tell a good retainer from an expensive habit.

These are the questions to ask a marketing agency before you sign anything. There are ten, they are plain, and a good provider will answer every one without discomfort. We publish our fixed monthly pricing partly for this reason: when the price and what it covers are already written down, most of these questions answer themselves.

They apply to any provider, including a freelancer and including us.

Why the retainer deserves a hard look

A marketing retainer is a fixed fee you pay every month for ongoing work. It is a sensible way to buy something that takes months, and it is also the easiest kind of bill to stop reading.

Two figures show what is at stake. Ahrefs surveyed 439 SEO service providers, and the most common monthly retainer they reported was $501 to $1,000, named by 20.4% of respondents. That is what providers say they charge, not what owners say they pay, and the respondents were worldwide and chose to take part.

Then look at the other side of the counter. In a LocaliQ survey of about 300 small businesses, 52% said their whole monthly marketing budget is under $1,000. For a lot of small businesses, one retainer is most of the budget. It should be bought as carefully as a piece of equipment.

Questions to ask a marketing agency about the work

1. What exactly do I get each month? A good answer is a list you could check off: this many pages written, the Google Business Profile updated weekly, one report, these ad campaigns managed. A weak answer is a list of nouns such as "strategy" and "optimization" with no quantity attached.

2. Who does the work? The person selling is often not the person doing. Ask for the name of whoever will handle your account, whether the work is done in house or sent out, and how many other clients that person carries. None of the answers is wrong. Not knowing is.

3. What do you need from me? Good marketing for a local business depends on things only you have: photos of real jobs, answers to customer questions, an hour a month on the phone. A provider who says they need nothing from you will be guessing about your business.

4. What will you not do? Every provider has edges. Some do not build websites, some do not touch ads, some will not write. Hearing the edges up front is a sign of experience.

Questions about ownership

5. Who owns the website, the Google Business Profile and the ad account? The answer you want is that you do, with the agency added as a manager. Those accounts hold your reviews, your ad history and your domain. If they are opened in the agency's name, leaving means starting over. We cover the website side of this in how to choose a web designer.

6. If you run ads, how much of my money reaches the ads? Ask for two separate numbers: what goes to the ad platform and what the agency keeps as its fee. A good answer lets you log into the ad account and see the spend yourself.

Questions about the term and the exit

7. What is the term, and how do I leave? Month to month marketing with thirty days' notice is the simplest arrangement to live with. A longer term is not automatically a trap, since some work takes months to show, but ask what you get in return for the commitment and what it costs to end early.

8. What do I keep when I leave? The pages written for you, the photos, the ad campaigns, the reporting history. Ask for the answer in writing. A provider confident in their work does not need to hold your material to keep you.

Questions about results

9. How will I know it is working? The honest measures are the ones you can feel in the business: calls, form submissions, booked jobs, and which of those came from the work you are paying for. Rankings and impressions are useful to the person doing the work. They are not the result.

10. How long before I should expect to see something? A straight answer usually involves months and comes without a promise. That is not evasion. Google's own guide to how Search works says it does not accept payment to rank a site higher, and does not guarantee it will crawl, index or show any page. Anyone guaranteeing a position is promising something that is not theirs to give.

Agency contract red flags

A few things in a contract or a sales call should slow you down:

  • A guaranteed ranking, or a guaranteed number of leads

  • Accounts opened in the agency's name instead of yours

  • A long term with an automatic renewal and no plain way out

  • A monthly report full of charts and no mention of calls or jobs

  • Pressure to sign this week

  • A price that only appears after a "strategy call"

One of these on its own may have an innocent explanation. Ask. Three together is a pattern.

To be fair to agencies, the reverse also happens. Owners sign, send nothing, skip the monthly call, and then wonder why the work is generic. If you are not ready to give a provider an hour a month, a retainer is the wrong purchase right now, and you would do better spending a small one-time sum on the basics.

When not to hire anyone yet

If your website does not clearly say what you do, where, and how to reach you, fix that before you pay for monthly marketing. Sending more people to a page that does not convert them is the most common waste we see in Oakland County, and no retainer cures it. Our guide to what a small business website costs in Michigan covers what that fix should run.

The next step

Take the ten questions to your next sales call and write the answers down as you go. Then put the same ten to a second provider and compare the two sheets.

If you want a second opinion on a proposal already on your desk, send it over for a free review. We will tell you which parts look fair and which we would push back on, whether or not you ever work with us.

The next stepFixed monthly pricingPublished prices, no build fee, no long contract.
StrategyPricing

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Leave a comment

Free, and no pitch

Want this done for your business? Tell us where you are.

Send a few details and we will look at your site and your Google presence, then tell you plainly what we would fix first. We reply within one business day.

Optional

Email or phone — one is required. We reply within one business day.

What do you need help with? *
What are you hoping to do?Optional

★ 5.0 on Google · Free · No pitch · We reply within one business day